Lately I have been getting a lot of flak on my position on “Enhanced interrogation” of terror suspects. I firmly believe that our country should not have institutionalized torture in any form, no matter what is at stake.
I don’t think that we as a country or a people should ever allow something like that to grow within any part of our government, police, or military. The main argument that I encounter is “Well, look what they do to ours and others that they capture”
That is the point; We are not them, we are Americans and to act like them would be, frankly, un-American. Why don’t we torture child killers to death? I know it sounds appealing, but we as a society, in our judgement of them, have also judged that we are not like them. Instead of a cruel and vicious death that would appease blood thirsty revenge, they are afforded the most comfortable death possible.
Now don’t get me wrong, I have no love for these people and if someone other than us were to torture them to death, I couldn’t care less. But we have to remember who we are as a people and as a country; We are the good guys and stand on our principles in righteousness.
Yes, I still believe in American exceptionalism; there are still a core group of Americans who represent the people and the ideals that this country was founded upon. It took Americans, the people who would not abide a king, to finally bring freedom and liberty into the world.
I am not exaggerating either about the difference between us and “them”. Read the quote below and you will get my point about “Un-American”
During the American Revolutionary War, George Washington and his Continental Army put the laws of war into practice regarding prisoners of war unlike their opponents who did not. The British believed that Colonial American soldiers were traitors and not entitled to POW status and would treat them as unlawful combatants and subject them to execution on the battlefield if captured as what happened at the Battle at Drake’s farm during the Forage War. The Americans took a different view. They believed that all captives should be taken prisoner. After winning the Battle of Trenton on Christmas Day 1776, Washington found himself left with hundreds of Hessian troops who had surrendered to the Americans. Washington ordered his troops to take the prisoners in and “treat them with humanity,” which they did. “Let them have no reason to complain of our copying the brutal example of the British army,” Washington said.[16] Some British and Hessian prisoners of war were paroled to American farmers. Their labor made up for shortages caused by the number of men serving in the Continental Army. (Wiki)
We have to decide who we are as a nation and personally, I don’t want to be a nation that tortures. Instead, I want to fight on the side that good old George fought on. If you do all things in righteousness, then when the battle comes to you, you are one hell of an opponent, knowing that right is on your side.
What is wrong when we have to keep prisoners on foreign soil because what happens there cannot be abided on American soil? What is wrong when you have to invent a special class of combatant so the treaties that we signed with good moral conscience don’t apply?
But in addition, there is more to it than just the moral component. Now that the government can declare terrorists enemy combatants, when can that be applied to us? Jose Padilla, an American citizen, was declared an enemy combatant and sent to Gitmo for 3 1/2 years. While he was there “Enhanced interrogation techniques” were used to attempt to garner information.
Eventually he was transferred stateside and tried and convicted in a civilian court. Yes, he was guilty, but how would we have known that without evidence being presented? Since when can a bunch of C.I.A. guys try convict and sentence someone? How did we know that Padilla didn’t stumble onto something like fast and furious and got shipped out to shut him up? Only because of the fact that evidence was presented that in the end was used to convict him.
Now here is the the thing about his conviction; they never charged him with what they accused him of. He was instead convicted of conspiring to fight in foreign Jihad.
The supreme court ended up making a ruling that was pretty fuzzy, but only after an appeals court ruled that his detention was legal.
After the NDAA 2012 and it’s indefinite military detention provision, how many laws away are we from becoming Jose Padilla?
I don’t think that where our country is headed right now is where I want it to be. I don’t think that it should be filled with people who are willing to abide indefinite detention and torture. I think that it should be filled with men like Washington who are filled with compassion and righteousness and are willing to do the right thing.
I myself may be no Washington, but I sure as hell will speak out for the principles that he believed in, even if I do get a load of crap from people on my side.
“In a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act” George orwell